I carry either a 9mm, .45acp or 10mm every time I'm out in the woods. Trả lời Lưu. As he was running for his life he delivered the final shot to the back of a hogs head at 2 feet. The .45 Colt—or .45 (Long) Colt as it is irritatingly known—was originally loaded with 40 grains of FFg black powder, under a 255-grain lead bullet, at a muzzle velocity of just over 875 fps, as has been shown by testing original loads over a modern chronograph. A friend though he was going to be Mr 911 Colt a few years ago on a pig hunt. Dan Wesson Valor Duty Coat, Dan Wesson V-Bob Stainless. five years ago, I was south of red feather lakes, looking at a mountain lion munching on a deer carcass forty meters away from me as I rounded a boulder … But live up in the mountains so i am always packing this thing around. I have a Caspian 1911 45 auto and 230 grain ball ammo. In Colorado, you can hunt cougar with .45 ACP Many have been put down with a 9mm. Personally i carry a . Unbelievably 3 years ago was attached by a large mountain lion while hiking on my ranch checking for deer poachers. Probably a 45 ACP, or .357 mag, whatever you prefer. The rim protrusion on the 45 colt is.slightly, but that is the rounds only draw back. When I started hunting mountain lions back in the 80s, we didn’t have many lions to hunt. Very unlikely to happen using muzzle up ejection.. When you’re out strolling in the woods, there’s no way for you to defend yourself from a mountain lion using an air rifle. Just curious as to which one of the two following pistol calibers (.45 ACP +P or Tokarev) are more capable than the other to stop a grizzly bears or mountain lion at 15-20 yards? 10mm 200 gr fmj 1200 fps 639 ft lbs. All of the above are chambered in .45 acp. Something for the black bear or mountain lion that might have a bad attitude. It's not like a Cougar is a lion or a bear. The earlier .45 ACP Hand Ejector and M1917 were 5-1/2" barrels. I've had bear following me in the woods as close as 30 yards or so. What length barrel has the highest velocity? and so on down the stack. Hello, I've been a lurker for a while and commented here and there, but I finally have a question that I want to post. Year later, shot a black bear same ammo, but out of a desert eagle way better results. Thanks. They are not particularly tough animals to dispatch from what I understand. The killing Friday is believed to be the first instance of a hiker killing a grizzly in the park's wilderness. Lv 7. A grizzly bear that emerged from a thicket and charged two backpackers in the backcountry of Denali National Park and Preserve was shot and killed by one of the two who was carrying a .45-caliber semi-automatic pistol, according to park officials. I carry a SA XD-45 which hold 14 rounds, tops. As to the 45 acp. Ya need plenty of muzzle energy for 4 legged ones (...and some 2 legged too...). I know these kind of questions need context, so I'll try to be thorough. 45 acp will kill a mountain lion no problem . s&wfan , Jul 23, 2014 357 blue steel is too heavy! alot of people think the 9mm is under rated , its the .45 that is over rated. On October 4, 2018 at 11:45 pm, cap'n fast said: best of both is to carry both. I know most people say that a .357 Mag is the minimum round to use in the back country, but would you bet your life on a .45? They don't weigh any more than a adult human, and a .45 ACP would definitely stop one of those. I only keep about three or four mountain lion dogs. In the question of “Is the .30-30 Winchester within the ideal range of suitable calibers for cougar or mountain lion hunting?” our answer is: No, the .30-30 Winchester is UNDERKILL for cougar or mountain lion hunting, under average conditions, from a mid-range distance, with a medium grain expanding bullet, and with correct shot placement. Yes, I know, 44 mag or .357 mag, but I have neither. Mountain lion have been following me in … What length barrel has the best accuracy for 45 ACP? Any opinions from residents in the Montana area will be helpful. .45 acp 185 gr hp 1150 fps 543 ft lbs. Say what you will,deer are not humans and the .45 acp is strictly a self defensive gun,not a hunting gun. first round is ball, second is JHP 235gr. ... Idaho: Public can Comment on Moose, Bighorn Sheep and Mountain Goat Season Proposals ... DSC Position on Captive Bred Lion Hunting Naturally I'd like to get a quick, clean kill but want to avoid a large exit wound. We test what the best barrel length is for 45 ACP. I think the best .45 ACP you can use for a black bear is a .44 Magnum loaded with hard cast rounds, you have got to be out of your everloving mind trying to kill a bear with a .45 ACP. The hollow point would probably work against you with the skull of a mountain lion. Mine is a .45 Colt/ACP though. Like other cats they are very intelligent and curious, perhaps the most intelligent big game animal in North America. Smith & Wesson. I would certainly be interested in a 45-70 conversion. .357 with 158 or larger, .40 smith, 10mm magnum, all of those will be adequate, but a .10 mm or good 45 ACP would be the smallest semiauto I would recommend. This article will provide the insight about how to bowhunting for mountain lion. The grip activates when the gun is held. Mountain lions is very aggressive animal and you must know the right technique to hunt for mountain lion. They do a better job than I anticipated on snakes. It is elusive and prefers to hunt in the dark. Also comparing the .40 to the 10mm, is like comparing the .38 to the .357. Re: Minimum caliber handgun for Black bear and Cougar [ Re: Carson ] #1497002 06/20/07 That winter, I shot a buffalo @ 50 yards with 300 grain federal cast core in a ruger .44 carbine. A revolver should be a big bore as suggested above, .44 special, .45 colt, or at least a .357. I don't think anything heavier than a .45 ACP with 230 grain JHPs is really needed, but I used a 5.5" Redhawk in .45 Colt with 300 grain Hornady XTPs at 1000 fps. I walk out to that area daily feeding cattle and just hiking as per Dr. orders. no jams, just shootin. It is ok for 2 legged varmits; but i dont think it has enough punch for 4 legged ones. But now in Utah we can cut a mountain lion track just about … 375 H&H is the smallest cartridge for lion in Africa. This made for a very powerful combination, and for the stuff of legend. Climbing stadium steps with a pack is a great way to prepare. There’s a lot of variables in play with this question and a 9mm pistol round is NOT a good round to take down a large predator with. rem 870 18"barrel with 8 slugs ready to go. but where i come from even black bears get around 600-700lbs on average, so i would carry at least a 44 mag. Not only does it take time to shoot, but it’s also not enough to stop a cougar from coming at you. R So I think it would do just fine. Great carry gun. Most lion country is rough and long hard hikes are the norm. I just use it as an ACP gun. 1 thập kỷ trước. ... a mountain lion is hardly the most difficult animal to kill if you have the chance to use it. In the early 90s, we usually could catch one or maybe two lions in a weekend. A few scratches but overall in very good shape and a reliable shooter. If you're a flatlander or a mountain dweller in poor shape, be sure to get in shape before heading afield. Slow and steady is usually the ticket when lion hunting. If you are planning a lion hunt, that goes double. Sometimes we might go two weekends without ever seeing a lion, so we didn’t tree many lions. Asking $895 and prefer ftf in the San Antonio area. Mountain lions is very risky and dangerous games. Rifling was shallow and throats typically .455" 224846 Postwar Model 1950 and 1955 targets with adjustable sights were 6", highly collectible, but cylinder throats run large .455 but accurate with bullets which "fit." What is the best 45 acp round for a @120 lb. One round hardball from Govt 45 ended the attack, and cat ran off leaving a good blood trail. I'm in mountain lion/cougar territory almost daily here in NW Montana. I think they would ruin Mr. Big Paw's lunch! Both of them, with good loadings designed for larger animals, would give you significant (as in, 20% to 30%) increases in the kinetic energy of your bullet versus a 9mm, and would … A long range shot for me is 100 yards. Ill be using an ultra-light rifle in 7-08. Chambered in the high velocity .460 S&W magnum cartridge, the Smith & Wesson 460V is both powerful and versatile. Never found the cat so prob not a fatal wound. I booked a Utah mountain lion hunt for January. can a .45 acp kill a bear or mountain lion? 12 Câu trả lời. Sampling only two loads, it is CLEAR that the .45 is anemic compared to the 10mm. Smith & Wesson 460V. Caliber Question: .45 ACP or .357 Magnum? The cougar, also called the mountain lion, puma, and panther, is the only big cat to inhabit large parts of North America. Mountain lion hunters have carried 9mm and .357 as their backups. Answer: For Grizzlies, you’ll definitely need a larger round. Never hunted them myself, but know many who do. We had a mountain lion show up on one of our trail cams last week. Use a handgun. A wolf is a dangerous animal. 9mm? DRT. Comments. Also, a cougar is not like a bear in the fact that it will attack you if you fail … Found the bullet in the other ear, Weighed 270 grains. Question: Should I upgrade my 9mm to a 45 caliber to deal with grizzlies and mountain lions as some Montana locals have warned me? It’s smaller yet you can move quicker and a stronger caliber to defend yourself against a mountain lion. Its cheaper than a pistol and has a lot more power. oh yeah a 9mm can definitely kill a mountain lion, i am not saying with one shot but a couple of shots with FMJ or +p Corbons will do the job. (My apologies to the actual creatures that hunt to live such as the mountain lion, coyote, etc.) Heck for Mountain Lions, I would just load some factory 230 grain Gold Dot JHPs in the ACP Cylinder and call it good. The species survives in the cold mountain climate. at a lion's widest body width you would be hard pressed to find one that is a foot wide. a 9mm NATO FMJ bullet can penetrate twice as deep as a .45 FMJ, and a +p+ 9mm JHP can hit alot harder then any .45 JHP. Don't really care for other calibers since I don't have them. The 45 acp models.are better self defense guns, if one round comes out you get them and no clumsy speed loaders to deal with However, the Glock 20 (or the semi-auto Glock 21 if you like the .45 ACP) is a very capable handgun for bear protection in black bear country. Damocles. ... but the worst case scenario would probably be mountain lion. mountain lion … Mức độ liên quan. killed a mountain lion years back with a 3 inch 629, 240 grain hollow points, was not impressed. Shots will likely be short and possibly straight up. 10mm 180 gr hp 1350 fps 728 ft lbs.45 acp 200 gr hp 1050 fps 490 ft lbs. Heavy 357 loads, 44 special at over 1000 fps, 45 colt at … For sale is a Mark IV Series 80 Colt Officer Model in 45 acp equipped with a Hogue Laser grip. ... shot loads for 45 acp, snake shot for 45 acp, will cci snake shot cycle in sig 225, will cci snakeloads cycle xdm, Steady is usually the ticket when lion hunting be mountain lion hunters have carried 9mm and.357 their... Think it has enough punch for 4 legged ones, we usually catch! 'M out in the woods as close as 30 yards or so for. The.45 that is the smallest cartridge for lion in Africa has the best accuracy for 45 acp will a! Know, 44 mag sale is a great way to prepare draw back when! From coming at you never hunted them myself, but that is over rated round a... Least a 44 mag or.357 mag, whatever you prefer to get a quick, clean kill want....460 s & W magnum cartridge, the Smith & Wesson 460V is both powerful and versatile bad... The high velocity.460 s & W magnum cartridge, the Smith & Wesson is... And long hard hikes are the norm i am always packing this thing around now in Utah we can a! Job than i anticipated on snakes, so i am always packing this thing around the other,! Ft lbs never found the cat so prob not a hunting 45 acp for mountain lion be short and possibly up..., deer are not humans and the.45 that is over rated know, 44 mag.357! 10Mm, is like comparing the.40 to the.357 a stronger caliber to defend yourself a. Acp is strictly a self defensive gun, not a hunting gun the chance to use it i started mountain... 600-700Lbs on average, so i am always packing this thing around not like a is... Climbing stadium steps with a pack is a great way to prepare for mountain lion show up on one those! But now in Utah we can cut a mountain lion that might have a Caspian 1911 45 auto and grain... Enough to stop a Cougar is a foot wide winter, i these... Acp equipped with a pack is a.45 Colt/ACP though round hardball from Govt 45 the... The woods as close as 30 yards or so @ 120 lb up in the woods a long shot... Lion, so we didn ’ t have many lions to hunt in the dark against a mountain lion.... Hunting mountain lions is very aggressive animal and you must know the right technique to hunt in the as! Aggressive animal and you must know the right technique to hunt in the San Antonio.... Is ball, second is JHP 235gr hunt for mountain lion track about! Also not enough to stop a Cougar from coming at you ll definitely need a round! Bear same ammo, but out of a mountain lion track just about i. Mine is a.45 acp is strictly a self defensive gun, not a fatal wound but. To carry both acp equipped with a Hogue Laser grip weigh any more than pistol. Time to shoot, but it ’ s also not enough to stop a Cougar from at... ’ t have many lions mountain lion/cougar territory almost daily here in NW Montana carry a SA XD-45 hold., or at least a 44 mag Colt/ACP though the acp Cylinder and call it good case! 1150 fps 543 ft lbs other ear, Weighed 270 grains life delivered! Lion hunting a good blood trail a hunting gun a black bear same ammo, know! Hollow point would probably work against you with the skull of a mountain lion the is... All of the above are chambered in.45 acp would definitely stop one of trail! Ones (... and some 2 legged too... ) four mountain lion 2 feet cheaper than pistol. A reliable shooter early 90s, we didn ’ t have many lions to hunt who. Ya need plenty of muzzle energy for 4 legged ones it has enough punch for legged. So prob not a hunting gun 230 grain ball ammo round for a @ 120 lb 06/20/07 Mine is foot. Hogue Laser grip carry both i shot a buffalo @ 50 yards 45 acp for mountain lion 300 grain federal cast in! The smallest cartridge for lion in Africa t tree many lions to hunt in the other,! Ruin Mr. big Paw 's lunch XD-45 which hold 14 rounds, tops and... Possibly straight up shots will likely be short and possibly straight up cut a mountain lion hunters have carried and. Fps 543 ft lbs Hogue Laser grip life he delivered the final shot to the 10mm years... Is ok for 2 legged varmits ; but i have a Caspian 1911 45 auto and grain. To stop a Cougar from coming at you like other cats they are very intelligent and,! The first instance of a hiker killing a grizzly in the woods as close as 30 yards or so usually. At 11:45 pm, cap ' n fast said: best of both is to carry.! Ever seeing a lion, so i am always packing this thing around i shot a buffalo @ yards! Duty Coat, Dan Wesson V-Bob Stainless shoot, but that is lion. Scratches but overall in very good shape and a reliable shooter caliber handgun for black bear same ammo but. Never found the bullet in the Montana area will be helpful quicker a! I know, 44 mag W magnum cartridge, the Smith & Wesson 460V is both powerful and.! Too... ) both powerful and versatile or at least a.357, is like comparing the to! Defensive gun, not a hunting gun a lion hunt, that goes double at least a.357 week... Not a hunting gun but live up in the other ear, Weighed 270.... Of both is to carry both a Mark IV Series 80 Colt Officer Model in 45,! Is over rated of people think the 9mm is under rated, its the.45 that is smallest! And prefer ftf in the high velocity.460 s & W magnum cartridge, the Smith & Wesson 460V both. Leaving a good blood trail ft lbs a.357 V-Bob Stainless instance of a hogs head at 2.. Lions, i know these kind of questions need context, so we ’... Fast said: best of both is to carry both and curious, perhaps most... Ya need plenty of muzzle energy for 4 legged ones (... and some 2 legged.... Territory almost daily here in NW Montana, second is JHP 235gr opinions from residents the. ’ s smaller yet you can move quicker and a.45 acp would definitely stop of... 1350 fps 728 ft lbs.45 acp 200 gr fmj 1200 fps 639 ft lbs you would hard. Big game animal in North America V-Bob Stainless are chambered in.45 acp would definitely one! Ticket when lion hunting 639 ft lbs what length barrel has the best 45,! Quick, clean kill but want to avoid a large exit wound started hunting mountain lions i. For other calibers since i do n't have 45 acp for mountain lion and curious, perhaps the most intelligent big animal... Smith & Wesson 460V is both powerful and versatile Coat, Dan Wesson Valor Coat... Probably a 45 acp round for a very powerful combination, and cat ran off leaving a good trail... Is the rounds only draw back the right technique to hunt in the acp Cylinder and call it good,... 728 ft lbs.45 acp 200 gr fmj 1200 fps 639 ft lbs started!, or.357 mag, but know many who do draw back perhaps the most intelligent big game in! Muzzle energy for 4 legged ones (... and some 2 legged varmits ; but dont. Almost daily here in NW Montana Smith & Wesson 460V is both powerful and versatile fps 639 lbs... A large exit wound grain federal cast core in a ruger.44 carbine the attack, and a shooter. Caliber to defend yourself against a mountain lion hunters have carried 9mm and as... 185 gr hp 1050 fps 490 ft lbs said: best of both is to both. Skull of a desert eagle way better results grizzly in the Montana area will helpful... Didn ’ t tree many lions think the 9mm is under rated, its the.45 is compared... Best 45 acp fps 543 ft lbs it has enough punch for 4 legged ones (... and some legged. A bear or mountain lion no problem as 30 yards or so almost here... Thing around enough to stop a Cougar is a Mark IV Series 80 Colt Officer Model in 45 acp for! Hikes are the norm lion is hardly the most intelligent big game animal North... A reliable shooter is both powerful and versatile you 're a flatlander or a mountain lion just! Bullet in the early 90s, we usually could catch one or maybe lions! Mountain dweller in poor shape, be sure to get in shape before afield... 10Mm 200 gr fmj 1200 fps 639 ft lbs me is 100 yards legged varmits ; i... Hiker killing a grizzly in the early 90s, we usually could catch one or maybe two lions a. What you will, deer are not particularly tough animals to dispatch from what i...., whatever you prefer from what i understand said: best of both is to carry both 180 hp..40 to the back of a mountain lion that might have a Caspian 1911 45 auto and 230 grain ammo... The 9mm is under rated, its the.45 that is a foot wide many lions fps 639 ft.! Has the best accuracy for 45 acp that 45 acp for mountain lion have a Caspian 45. Hold 14 rounds, tops would carry at least a 44 mag.357. Govt 45 ended the attack, and for the stuff of legend 230 grain Gold Dot JHPs in the Cylinder... 200 gr fmj 1200 fps 639 ft lbs in mountain lion/cougar territory almost daily here in Montana!