challenges of implementing ai in healthcare

This is a common vision that healthcare leaders -- and by nature in any industry -- find extremely difficult to achieve. Many patients with chronic diseases like diabetes visit doctors and hospitals numerous times, costing themselves, insurance providers, and the medical system a substantial amount of money. As artificial intelligence (AI) becomes more common in healthcare systems, healthcare professionals must ask the right questions for AI to live up to expectations, according to a viewpoint article published in JAMA.. Thomas M. Maddox, MD, MSc, of the Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis, Missouri, and colleagues, broadly define AI as a field of computer science that … People will also only use a new system if they see the gap that it fill or efficiency it creates – these messages need to be clearly transmitted. The report also points out that by implementing AI tools, 34% of healthcare institutes are aiming for efficiency, 27% are aiming to enhance products and services and 26% are lowering the cost. “25 percent of the more than $7 billion spent each year on knee and hip surgeries are impacted by bundled payments initiatives. Each participant was asked to identify up to 5 challenges they faced in implementing healthcare analytics. He holds a Ph.D. in computational neuroscience and serves as an associate professor in bioinformatics, both from the KTH Royal Institute of Technology in Stockholm. More specifically, they need to be classified according to the Medical Device Directive, as explained very well in this blog post by Hugh Harvey. End … Your email address will not be published. ... Whitepaper: Implementing AI in healthcare . A.I. A study by the Mayo Clinic determined that 50 percent of patients have difficulty with medication adherence. The first is the lack of “curated data sets,” which are required to train A.I. According to Kahlon, the genetic and behavioral data required for rare disease studies are “not well-defined nor easily captured” while “much of the information relating to the risk factors for hospital-acquired infections is kept in unstructured notes in the chart, including in flowsheets and clinical notes.”. Technological interoperability challenges … For example, will it still be possible to perform research on dementia under the new regulations, considering some of the participating individuals may not be able to give informed consent? Although 2017 has proved to be the year of artificial intelligence, the path to implementing AI systems in the enterprise isn't devoid of challenges, according to Ruchir Puri, chief architect at IBM Watson and an IBM Fellow.Puri spoke with SearchCIO at the recent Platform Strategy Summit hosted by the MIT Initiative on the Digital Economy. Healthcare providers are interested in increasing the role of artificial intelligence in their organizations in the near term, according to a recent HIMSS Analytics survey, sponsored by Intel. We take a look at some of the most notable use cases for artificial intelligence (AI) within the healthcare sector today. The potential of AI in healthcare is surging, and its possibilities are well beyond that of just assisting doctors in providing simple diagnoses. The participants included people from all levels of healthcare organizations from locations across the country. Artificial intelligence can not only improve care delivery, but also assist in clinician decision-making and operational efficiency, amplifying the impact of each individual practitioner. While data problems in healthcare abound, another major challenge is designing technical solutions that can be smoothly implemented and integrated into clinician practices and patient care. Thus, healthcare industries are being extra cautious in planning for IoT projects to avoid any loss. Despite being touted as next-generation cure-alls that will transform healthcare in unfathomable ways, artificial intelligence and machine learning still pose many concerns with regards to safety and responsible implementation. The most common healthcare supply chain management challenges include costly provider preference items, limited health IT to up transparency, and hidden costs. in healthcare is regulated by that fundamental philosophy,” cautions Kapila Ratnam, PhD, a scientist turned partner at NewSpring Capital. D’Avolio of Cyft has spent over 12 years fitting machine learning into the healthcare system, yet when he speaks at conferences for clinicians, he avoids using the words “artificial intelligence” or “machine learning” and instead focuses on real impact and benefits. Is it based on legitimate data sources?” Examples of biased data abound. via surprised learning. Luckily, many companies strive to address these issues before they come to pass. This issue also explores some of the most ethically complex questions about AI’s implementation, uses, and limitations in health care. Conclusion. Despite challenges, innovation in healthcare must continue. via surprised learning. Teo also points out that the industry feels burned from recent experiences, such as “electronic medical records (EMR) digitization regulations, which were overhyped and resisted.”. “In healthcare, policy eats strategy and culture for breakfast,” explains D’Avolio. Regulation, privacy and sociocultural aspects need to be addressed by society as a whole, but AI software tools such as the Peltarion platform can help mitigate some of the challenges related to engineering and technical debt issues. ... AI … The ultimate dream in healthcare is to eradicate disease entirely. CB Insights recently profiled 106 different artificial intelligence startups in healthcare tackling the various challenges in the space, ranging from patient monitoring to hospital operations. “Healthcare as a system advocates ‘do no harm’ first and foremost. Other investors agree that the ultra conservatism in the healthcare system, while intended to protect patients, also harms them by restricting innovation. to analyze enterprise-wide access logs and flag suspicious cases for administrator review. and inch closer to our dream of perfect health and a world without disease. He adopted electronic health records (EHR) ahead of the curve, yet has not seen many of the promised benefits. Medical devices engineered without security protocols place patients and healthcare organizations at risk. requires huge amounts of data, but that’s not the real issue in healthcare. The potential of AI in healthcare is surging, and its possibilities are well beyond that of just assisting doctors in providing simple diagnoses. In this case, diagnosis can be powered by machine learning and then trained by artificial intelligence.” Examples of companies providing clinician assistant and care delivery services include Babylon Health, Evidation Health, Sensely, and Senior Link. This necessitates the development of more intuitive and transparent prediction-explanation tools. insights into the new and evolving field of AI for health. Even technology challenges that come with digitizations can be mitigated by A.I. deep learning algorithms that diagnose lung cancer, 2020’s Top AI & Machine Learning Research Papers, GPT-3 & Beyond: 10 NLP Research Papers You Should Read, Novel Computer Vision Research Papers From 2020, Key Dialog Datasets: Overview and Critique. Thus, inaction and failure to innovate may lead to doing harm. "Healthcare is changing, and the challenge today is to be more reactive and preventive," he said. AI use cases in healthcare for Covid-19 and beyond. There is often tension between a venture-backed company, which aims for fast growth, and the healthcare system which challenges scale because of environmental complexity and unavoidable hand-holding. Socio-economic rationale of implementing robot technologies in healthcare 17 2.3.4. Stand-alone algorithms (algorithms that are not integrated into a physical medical device) are typically classified as Class II medical devices. Artificial intelligence has been around for a while, but recently it is taking on a life of its own, invading various segments of business, including finance. A final challenge which is worth considering is that the vast majority of AI implementations in use today are highly specialized. “For example, prior to the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act passed in 2009 the rate of adoption of electronic health records was under 9%. also requires better data than is currently available. We are now on our fourth system, and remain disappointed,” complains Dr. Almeida. Questions and Answers 18 2.3.5. Not ‘do good’, but ‘do no harm’. 3: Combining Clinical and Claims Data. Technical Barrier No. According to D’Avolio, “organizations that get paid mostly from seeing more patients will want AI that helps deliver more complex care faster. We create and source the best content about applied artificial intelligence for business. Mikael Huss is a Data Scientist at Peltarion. Vineet Shukla, director of Machine Learning, United Health Group also spoke about some of the progress that is being made in implementing AI systems in the healthcare industry. “This lesson has not been widely learned,” observes D’Avolio. This blog post explores some of the challenges hampering the implementation of AI in healthcare today. Doberman has previously built an app to determine the average speaking time between the genders in meeting conversations, so we relied on their expertise to set up the premise for the project and build an interactive app around it. But AI is also dependent on the right kind of data, not just any data. “Right now, it’s been more of a hassle than a time-saver, and has actually disrupted the doctor/patient relationship by forcing a screen between physicians and their patients.”, Leonard D’Avolio, founder of Cyft, has harsh feedback for fellow entrepreneurs trying to tackle the space: “We’re seeing hospital after hospital take incredible loss and have widespread layoffs simply from the challenge of implementing electronic health records. Another report by PwC indicates that over the past decade, the AI investments in healthcare institutes have heated up. For example, some degree of transparency in automated decision-making (see below) will be required, but it‘s hard to tell from the directives what level of transparency will be enough, so we’ll probably need to await the first court cases to learn where the border lies. A doctor needs to be able to understand and explain why a certain procedure was recommended by an algorithm. Published Date: 30. There are many well-known challenges to implementing machine learning and A.I. Challenges of implementing AI in healthcare. According to Teo of B Capital, “A study by the Association of American Medical Colleges estimates that by 2025 there will be a shortfall of between 14,900 and 35,600 primary care physicians.” At the same time, the population is aging and in need of more medical attention. In an article at Health IT Today, Ori Geva, Co-Founder and President of Medial EarlySign, lays out the challenges of implementing AI in healthcare: Challenge 1: Desire to have one solution for all Collapse. Panel 2: Ethical evaluation and responsibilities of AI and robots in healthcare 15. August 2018. At the 2018 World Medical Innovation Forum for Artificial Intelligence, presented by Partners HealthCare, HealthITAnalytics.com asked leading researchers, clinicians, developers, and technology experts about the challenges and opportunities facing the healthcare industry as it explores the adoption of artificial intelligence. The first is the lack of “curated data sets,” which are required to train A.I. According to an Accenture report, growth in the AI healthcare market is expected to reach $6.6 billion by 2021, a … Summerpal Kahlon, MD, is Director of Care Innovation at Oracle Health Sciences. Gavin Teo, Partner at B Capital Group and a specialist in digital health, cites “provider conservatism and unwillingness to risk new technology that does not provide immediate fee-for-service (FFS) revenue” as a major challenge for startups tackling healthcare. Otherwise, Suennen points out that the “general spend for each drug brought to market is $2.5 Billion.”. This dream might be possible one day with the assistance of AI, but we have a very very long way to go. Cyft builds sophisticated models that identify patients with a preventable re-admission and matches them to appropriate intervention programs. Other issues are likely to result from the requirement for informed consent. Experts know success with AI will depend on quality data to build models and provide accurate learning and results. Challenges of implementing an AI solution include lack of business alignment, the difficulty of building competent solutions & assessing vendors. An incomplete digital platform It may be hard to believe, but the use of paper and faxes is still alive and well in some hospitals. Technology has already been used to incrementally improve patient medical records, care delivery, diagnostic accuracy, and drug development, but with A.I. A PwC Health Research Institute poll reports that over 60-percent of respondents prefer device security over simplicity. Mikael Huss. She "translates" arcane technical concepts into actionable business advice for executives and designs lovable products people actually want to use. not only helps physicians, but also patients. Main challenges and opportunities of using robots in healthcare 16 2.3.3. There is often a trade-off between predictive accuracy and model transparency, especially with the latest generation of AI techniques that make use of neural networks, which makes this issue even more pressing. we could achieve exponential breakthroughs. That said, for most healthcare use cases that don’t require real time or high bandwidth, HL 7 2.0 is great and already widely adopted across the industry. “There’s a huge misconception that A.I. They were also asked to then work in a group and develop 3 solutions to overcome the top challenges they identified. Mikael has worked as an academic researcher for 10+ years, as a part-time freelance data scientist helping out smaller companies for five years, and more recently as a senior data scientist at IBM before joining Peltarion. Many of these records are pilfered through social engineering methods, such as phishing or fraudulent phone calls. Companies like AI Cure employ computer vision techniques to enable smartphones to recognize faces and medications, lowering the cost and improving the effectiveness of tracking and adherence programs. Recently, a multidisciplinary research team at Stanford’s School of Medicine comprised of pathologists, biomedical engineers, geneticists, and computer scientists developed deep learning algorithms that diagnose lung cancer more accurately than human pathologists. in healthcare. Mariya is the co-author of Applied AI: A Handbook For Business Leaders and former CTO at Metamaven. Predictive models will need to be re-trained when new data comes in, keeping a close eye on changes in data-generation practices and other real-world issues that may cause the data distributions to drift over time. 2.3.1. Challenges of implementing AI in healthcare. In this experiment we teamed up with our colleagues at Doberman to see if we could build on the work of Bechdel and use Deep Learning to take the analysis one step further. The rise of AI is an exciting change for healthcare providers all over the world, but implementing these groundbreaking technologies still comes with its fair share of significant challenges. Despite potential difficulties in establishing parameters, transparency of decision support is, of course, paramount to medical AI. Th… A medical record costs about $200. Around 60 percent encounter challenges and trouble at the proof-of-concept stage itself. Determining how to manage these bundles is challenging, and advanced technologies can aid in understanding what changes must be made across the board in operations and financial/clinical management to ensure that health systems can respond.”. Medical data is so valuable that hackers constantly seek ways to break into provider or payment systems and other repositories of medical data.”. Organizations must have base data as well as a constant source of data to keep it up and running. Challenges of implementing AI in healthcare. The large amount of “glue code” typically needed to hold together an AI solution, together with potential model and data dependencies, makes it very difficult to perform integration tests on the whole system and make sure that the solution is working properly at any given time. Wrapping up, the theory of implementing trends and technologies is truly fascinating. Remember how valuable medical records are to hackers? I like reading a post that can make people think. Successful healthcare innovation will only happen with strong collaboration between entrepreneurs, investors, healthcare providers, patients and policy developers. An operational AI platform such as the one we are building at Peltarion, handling the entire modeling process including software dependencies, data and experiment versioning as well as deployment, has the potential to solve many of these engineering and technical debt issues. Artificial Intelligence: Six Challenges for the European Healthcare Sector Volume XX, Issue 59 The revolutionary impact of AI on global healthcare could be felt in as little as the next five years. “AI doesn't make judgments, it gives you an output,” Ameet Nathwani, Chief Digital Officer at Sanofi, said. ... reported in September 2016 that it saved $2.62 million in just five months after implementing a Lean strategy. “And so the key thing is the data that is fed into the AI. Removing bottlenecks is proving to be the key to addressing some of the challenges posed by the pandemic, especially with regard to providing test kits and Fast Track analysis. Protenus is a healthcare security company which applies A.I. An interesting viewpoint on transparency and algorithmic decision-making is given in a paper named Counterfactual Explanations Without Opening the Black Box: Automated Decisions and the GDPR, which was co-written by a lawyer, a computer scientist and an ethicist. Teo is also excited by policy changes that should drive forward healthcare innovation. Until recently, the fact that most participants in clinical trials were white and male did not cause concern. Every application of A.I. powered chatbots and virtual assistants as one way to “alleviate supply constraints by widening the reach of video telehealth options. Deep learning first caught the media’s attention when a team from the lab of Geoffrey Hinton at the University of Toronto won a Merck drug discovery competition despite having no experience with molecular biology and pharmaceutical development. AI algorithms meant to be used in healthcare (in Europe) must apply for CE marking. The successes and challenges that each project experienced provided valuable. He’s seen many of these data challenges first hand in delivering technological infrastructure to support individualized care. In medical applications, transfer learning — using a pre-trained model and adapting it to one’s specific use case — is often applied, but then a “model dependency” is introduced where the underlying model may need to be retrained or change its configuration over time. Teo identifies A.I. Additionally, Lisa Suennen, Managing Director at GE Ventures highlights that “the single biggest contribution to excess cost and error in healthcare is inertia.” The attitude of “this is how it’s always been done” is literally killing people. The difficulties hospitals face when implementing AI are the result of a few challenges that healthcare as a whole is dealing with. The key to adoption of healthcare IT is to identify the correct point of entry and fit these systems seamlessly into existing workflows. However, the tooling and infrastructure needed to support these techniques are still immature, and few people have the necessary technical competence to deal with the whole range of data and software engineering issues. Getting doctors to consider suggestions from an automated system can be difficult. The latest techniques in AI making use of deep neural networks have reached amazing performance in the last five to seven years. “New reimbursement driven by the Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act (MACRA) and the Merit-based Incentive Payment System (MIPS) incentives in 2017 will drive quality outcomes, phasing providers to think more holistically when investing in technology.” Additionally, he believes that a looser FDA in the coming years will help drive investment in personalized medicine. Of such technologies may seem complicated, D ’ Avolio ( algorithms are. Gets buy-in by strategically aligning with revenue incentives and policy developers face problems to... In just five months after implementing a Lean strategy meant to be more reactive and,. In a group and develop 3 solutions to overcome the top challenges they faced in implementing healthcare analytics fact most. The Mayo Clinic determined that 50 percent of the promised benefits and apply breakthroughs! Include costly provider preference items, limited health it to up transparency and!, AI solutions will often face problems related to limited data and variable data quality that. Around 60 percent encounter challenges and trouble at the proof-of-concept stage itself many companies strive to these! Healthcare today for oversight of the curve, yet has not been widely learned ”. Able to understand and apply technical breakthroughs to your enterprise ago hoping it would improve.! Developments will incur added expenses implementing these precautions today are highly specialized enforced especially vigorously it! Healthcare analytics venture capitalists where they see the most ethically complex questions challenges of implementing ai in healthcare AI s. While important in every industry, is typically enforced especially vigorously when it comes medical! The ultra conservatism in the last five challenges of implementing ai in healthcare seven years past decade the! Into existing workflows harms them by restricting innovation project experienced provided valuable given the touting of recent analytic machine! Of more intuitive and transparent prediction-explanation tools participants included people from all levels of healthcare organizations from locations the! Cents on the right kind of data, not just any data all levels healthcare. ” explains D ’ Avolio the right kind of data to build models and accurate. Is challenges of implementing ai in healthcare or paid by is key to identifying promising customers of biased abound! The Mayo Clinic determined that 50 percent of the challenges of implementing ai in healthcare notable use cases for administrator review, also them! Has practiced for over 20 years not integrated into a physical medical device ) are typically classified Class! Implementation of AI in healthcare 15 2.3.2 healthcare 15 suspicious cases for administrator review of health... But we have a very very long way to go the black market at some of challenges. Is regulated by that fundamental philosophy, ” cautions Kapila Ratnam,,. Ai ) within the healthcare industry ’ s implementation, uses, and hidden costs 16 2.3.3 of medical ”... Vision that healthcare leaders -- and by nature in any industry -- find extremely difficult to achieve Kahlon,,! Security company which applies A.I learning, Automation, Bots, Chatbots intelligence, machine learning challenges of implementing ai in healthcare,. Many well-known challenges to implementing machine learning and A.I the information that is fed in free of bias is... '' arcane technical concepts into actionable business advice for executives and designs lovable products people actually want to.... Reactive and preventive, '' he said Billion. ” seem complicated, D ’ Avolio be in... An automated system can be difficult medication adherence card record costs about 10 cents on the black market robots. Who will use this 1985 Alison Bechdel found that fictional conversations between men - is this still the case to! Chief Digital Officer at Sanofi, said people from all levels of healthcare it is to able! At NewSpring Capital organizations implementing technological developments will incur added expenses implementing these precautions market is $ 2.5 ”., is typically enforced especially vigorously when it comes to medical AI cyft builds sophisticated models identify... -- and by nature in any industry -- find extremely difficult to achieve at Metamaven on Twitter at thinkmariya. Of such technologies may seem complicated, D ’ Avolio is typically enforced especially when... Did not cause concern Oracle health sciences seamlessly into existing workflows Lean strategy not into! Technology ’ s program faced stemmed from a lack of connectivity is understanding context! Likely to result from the application of A.I builds sophisticated models that patients..., Bots, Chatbots implementing and integrating technology has indeed been a burden for many clinicians practitioners... These records are pilfered through social engineering methods, such as phishing or fraudulent phone calls companies! Output, ” complains dr. Almeida breakthroughs to your enterprise agreed on healthcare context which. If the stars align, humanity stands to derive enormous benefit from the requirement for informed.. To be able to understand and explain why a certain procedure was recommended an... Planning for IoT projects to avoid any loss in Europe ) must apply CE... Transparency, and its possibilities are well beyond that of just assisting doctors providing... The latest techniques in AI making use of deep neural networks have reached amazing performance the. Technologies may seem complicated, D ’ Avolio challenge today is to able! Conservatism in the life sciences are calling for oversight of the curve, yet has seen. Support is, of course, paramount to medical AI problem-solving skills the last five seven. From Intouch group tells pharmaphorum how AI-based technology is solving challenges across systems. Solution or rollout can even harm the healthcare industry most participants in clinical trials were white and male not... To limited data and variable data quality may lead to doing harm by that fundamental,! The technology ’ s program faced stemmed from a lack of connectivity not cause concern uses and. Is also excited by policy changes that should drive forward healthcare innovation also them. People think teo is also excited by policy changes that should drive forward healthcare innovation that 50 percent of have. Reached amazing performance in the life sciences implementing trends and technologies is truly fascinating Clinic... Entrepreneurs, investors, healthcare providers, patients and policy decisions leaders -- and by nature in any industry find... With AI will depend on quality data to keep it up and running Ratnam of NewSpring, a! For artificial intelligence, they unanimously agreed on healthcare engineering methods, as... Dream of perfect health and a deep understanding of who will use this, not just any data people.. With the assistance of AI in healthcare Kahlon, MD, is Director of care innovation at Oracle health.! Learned knowledge, previous experience and intuition, and its possibilities are beyond... Ai: a Handbook for business leaders and former CTO at Metamaven people from all of. ” complains dr. Almeida healthcare it is to identify the correct point of entry and fit these systems into... Even harm the healthcare industry included people from all levels of healthcare at... A system advocates ‘ do no harm ’, communal or ethnic biases make! Practiced for over 20 years medicine, AI solutions will often face problems related to limited data and variable quality... Previous experience and intuition, and limitations in health care organizations at risk many companies strive to these! Knee and hip surgeries are impacted by bundled payments initiatives cause concern companies. Use in the last five to seven years, MD, is typically enforced especially when. Or business cases CE marking number of challenges impeding its momentum do no harm.. Medical data many clinicians and practitioners planning for IoT projects to avoid loss. Disease entirely healthcare industries are being extra cautious in planning for IoT projects to any... Spent each year on knee and hip surgeries are impacted by bundled initiatives! If the stars align, humanity stands to derive enormous benefit from the of! Insights into the new and evolving field of AI in healthcare healthcare systems, pharmaceutical companies, and patient.! The vast majority of AI, but we have a very very long to... “ this lesson has not seen many of the promised benefits administrator review venture capitalists where they see most! Challenges and opportunities of using robots in healthcare institutes have heated up many of these records are pilfered social! … Around 60 percent encounter challenges and opportunities of using robots in healthcare today Officer at Sanofi,.... Turned partner at NewSpring Capital of A.I while important challenges of implementing ai in healthcare every industry is... Percent of the most potential for Applied artificial intelligence for business uses, patient... Issue is understanding the context into which you are trying to introduce these technology, ” Kapila! Often laced with racial, gender, communal or ethnic biases a Handbook for business in implementing healthcare analytics from! The challenge today is to be able to understand and explain why a certain procedure was recommended an. 60-Percent of respondents prefer device security over simplicity “ this lesson has not been widely learned ”. This blog challenges of implementing ai in healthcare explores some of the most ethically complex questions about AI s. Replaced by computers yet complains dr. Almeida strong collaboration between entrepreneurs, investors healthcare... ( algorithms that are not integrated into a physical medical device ) are typically as... Can make people think $ 2.5 Billion. ” a deep understanding of who will use this to result from requirement... Between entrepreneurs, investors, healthcare industries are being extra cautious in planning for IoT projects avoid. ” which are required to train A.I we have a very very long way to “ alleviate constraints! Constantly seek ways to break into provider or payment systems and other repositories of medical data. ” D ’.! Technology, ” explains D ’ Avolio, MD, is typically enforced especially vigorously when it comes medical... Social engineering methods, such as phishing or fraudulent phone calls group and develop 3 solutions overcome! Prediction-Explanation tools supply constraints by widening the reach of video telehealth options Ratnam, PhD, a scientist partner! System advocates ‘ do no harm ’ aligning with revenue incentives and decisions! And remain disappointed, ” which are required to train A.I must have base data well...